Our Viewpoint | Aarto Demerit Points system
"In that respect, a demerit system that imposes real consequences on repeat offenders is both necessary and overdue."
The long-awaited implementation of the Administrative Adjudication of Road Traffic Offences (Aarto) demerit points system in municipalities such as Msunduzi marks an important moment in South Africa’s efforts to improve road safety.
For many motorists, however, it is also the arrival of a system that has long been viewed with anxiety and apprehension. After years of delays, court challenges and administrative setbacks, Aarto is finally here.
The key question now is not whether the system has been implemented, but whether it will be capable of delivering meaningful change on the ground. South Africa’s road safety crisis is not simply the result of poor driver behaviour.
ALSO READ | Demerit points system set to hit Pietermaritzburg roads
It is also a consequence of weak, inconsistent and often inadequate enforcement of traffic laws. Reckless driving, speeding, dangerous overtaking, ignoring lane discipline and other violations have become commonplace partly because too many offenders believe the chances of being caught — and penalised — remain low.
In that respect, a demerit system that imposes real consequences on repeat offenders is both necessary and overdue. Yet the effectiveness of Aarto will depend entirely on how fairly and consistently it is enforced.
Municipalities such as Msunduzi have expressed confidence in their readiness, but past experience suggests caution is warranted.
Many municipalities continue to struggle with enforcing even basic traffic laws and by-laws. Illegal parking, overloaded vehicles, dangerous public transport practices and heavy truck infringements frequently go unchecked because of stretched resources and limited enforcement capacity.
ALSO READ | Don’t click: KZN warns motorists about fake traffic fine links
Aarto must also be applied evenly. It cannot become a system that disproportionately targets ordinary private motorists while repeat offenders in the taxi, bus and freight sectors escape proper scrutiny. Fair enforcement is essential if the system is to command public trust and credibility.
Equally important is the technology that underpins the system. A modern, technology-driven enforcement regime requires reliable cameras, monitoring systems and data infrastructure.
High-risk accident zones require better surveillance — not only to detect speeding, but also reckless driving and dangerous lane violations.
Government deserves credit for persisting with a reform that was decades in the making. But unless Aarto is backed by stronger enforcement, adequate funding and better technology, it risks becoming another well-intentioned policy that fails to make South Africa’s roads safer.
