Add as a preferred source on Google

The investigating officer in the Camperdown sister murder case has stood firm that the accused confessed to taking part in her sister’s murder, despite the defence strongly disputing the claim.

Sergeant Mfanuvele Gumede, from the uMgungundlovu District Task Team, told the Camperdown Magistrate’s Court on Thursday that Nikiwe Mngwengwe (46) admitted involvement in her sister’s murder during an interview conducted at the time of her arrest on May 22.

ALSO READ | Officer calls woman accused of plotting sister’s murder ‘heartless’

Under cross-examination, Mngwengwe’s defence attorney, who is identified in court as Miss Zondi and refused to give The Witness her first name, rejected this version, telling the court her client denies ever making a confession or being interviewed by Gumede.

Zondi said the defence would abide by Magistrate Siyabonga Ngcobo’s decision to subpoena all individuals allegedly present during the interview.

Gumede testified that Mngwengwe was informed of her rights, including her right to legal representation, before the interview took place.

He said those present included her aunt, two police officers and a security guard, adding that statements had been obtained from relatives, who were at the house during the arrest.

The defence raised no objection to the subpoenas, maintaining that no interview or confession occurred.

ALSO READ | Family torn apart as woman appears in court over sister’s killing

The court also heard that Gumede visited Westville Prison on Tuesday after Mngwengwe claimed she had not received medical treatment while in custody.

He told the court that prison officials confirmed she had received care.

Zondi, however, argued that her client had since been victimised following the visit.

“She was told she is causing problems for the prison,” Zondi said.

The defence further requested that Mngwengwe be transferred to another facility or held at a police station, but Gumede maintained Westville Prison was appropriate, particularly as she required medical attention.

ALSO READ | Northdale crackdown targets drug trade as cough syrup stash uncovered

Zondi also argued that denying bail would negatively affect Mngwengwe’s seven-year-old child, who would be displaced.

Mngwengwe on Monday told the court that she was the sole breadwinner at her home and was supporting her children, aged seven and 25.

Gumede rejected this, saying the victim’s children had already been left without a mother.

“In this case, there are children who are now orphans. Why should Mngwengwe’s child be prioritised?” he said.

He opposed bail, alleging that Mngwengwe had interfered with the investigation by threatening witnesses.

The bail application continues.