UKZN law students’ lives thrown into turmoil after exam paper leak

University of KwaZulu-Natal law students say their lives have been thrown into turmoil after being ordered to rewrite several first-semester LLB examinations with just 10 days’ notice, following the leaking of the exam papers.

The University of KwaZulu-Natal (UKZN) confirmed it has commissioned an independent external forensic investigation into the incident, saying the decision to re-administer the examinations is necessary to protect the integrity of its assessment process and the credibility of its qualifications.

ALSO READ | PMB youth dialogue tackles GBV, substance abuse and teen pregnancy

Fourth-year students from the Howard College and Pietermaritzburg campuses told The Witness they received emails at 7.53 pm on July 3 informing them that several law examinations they had already completed would have to be rewritten, after the university discovered that some examination papers had been compromised.

By then, both the main and supplementary examination periods had ended, and many students had already travelled home, started vacation employment or made other commitments during the semester break.

In a letter seen by The Witness, the university said it had identified concerns regarding the integrity of certain first-semester LLB examination materials.

ALSO READ | UKZN develops smart diabetes device to help elderly manage medication

To uphold the integrity, fairness, and credibility of the assessment process and to ensure that no student is unfairly advantaged or disadvantaged, the university has decided to re-administer the affected examinations.

The affected modules include Administrative Law, Bioethics, Constitutional Law, Income Tax, International Law and Maritime Law at Howard College, while Maritime Law and Succession will be rewritten at the Pietermaritzburg campus.

Main examinations are scheduled to be rewritten between July 13 and 15, while supplementary examinations will take place between July 22 and 24.

UKZN executive director for corporate services Dr Normah Zondi said the university had appointed independent forensic investigators to determine the source, nature and extent of the breach.

The university acknowledges the inconvenience this decision may cause to students who were not involved in the incident. However, maintaining the integrity and fairness of the assessment process is fundamental to protecting the value of UKZN qualifications and ensuring confidence among students, employers, professional bodies and the broader public.

ALSO READ | WATCH | KZN youth urged to seize digital economy opportunities

Zondi said the School of Law would implement academic support measures, including a catch-up plan, to assist affected students in meeting semester-two academic requirements.

The investigation would establish the facts surrounding the incident and identify those responsible, she said.

“Appropriate disciplinary, civil and, where applicable, criminal action will be pursued against those found responsible,” she said.

Students, however, argue that the impact extends far beyond inconvenience, saying the decision has placed them under financial strain, disrupted long-arranged plans and caused serious emotional distress.

ALSO READ | WATCH | Google bets on South Africa with new AI and cloud investments

One student said many had organised travel, accommodation, employment and family commitments around the university’s academic calendar.

I am currently away on a pre-booked trip that was arranged only after the completion of all examinations. The university’s decision has therefore placed me, and many other students, in an impossible position.

Students were now forced to cancel travel plans, absorb unexpected costs and return to campus at short notice, she said.

ALSO READ | How much does it really cost to raise a child on a grant?

“Students are now required to cancel or amend pre-booked travel arrangements, incurring substantial financial losses in the process.

“We will have to return to campus at very short notice and resume examination preparation after believing the semester had concluded. This will also result in considerable emotional and psychological stress on us,” she said.

Another student said the compressed timetable would require some students to write four or even five examinations over three days, more than a month after they had originally completed them.

ALSO READ | KZN schools bring home 24 trophies at national choral championships

“The university has consistently encouraged students to prioritise their mental health and wellbeing through counselling services, wellness initiatives and student support programmes. It is therefore deeply concerning that students have been placed under immense psychological pressure by this decision. With the new timetable, we are writing four, some are writing five modules over the space of three days. Under the original timetable, our examinations were more spread out. Many students who live outside KwaZulu-Natal also did not budget for these additional expenses,” he said.

A final-year LLB student described receiving the late-night notification as devastating.

“I haven’t been able to eat or sleep due to the stress of having to study so much content all over again in only 10 days. This content took months to learn, and much of it has already faded from memory.

ALSO READ | WATCH | School almost complete for high-performing pupils in rural KZN

I am in such a deep state of depression that my parents sought psychiatric help for me and intend sending the bill to the university. Financially, this could cost me my career. I was supposed to start vacation work today, which could ultimately have led to articles at that firm. However, I had to explain that I could no longer make it.

She also criticised the university’s decision to allow students to choose between rewriting the main or supplementary examinations, arguing that supplementary examinations are intended as a safety net for students who fail their main examinations, and were never designed to serve as an alternative examination sitting.